Welcome to choof.org. Unfair. Unbalanced. |
More Links Reenhead |
July 24, 2004
Tyranny of Petty Coercion Marilynne Robinson's essay on The Tyranny of Petty Coercion is excerpted in Harper's Magazine. She writes in part: "Moral and intellectual courage are not in nearly so flourishing a state (compared to physical courage), even though the risks they entail--financial or professional disadvantage, ridicule, ostracism--are comparatively minor...They threaten or violate loyalty, group identity, the sense of comme il faut. They are, intrinsically, outside the range of consensus." [...] It is sad to consider how much first-rate courage must be devoted in this world to struggling out of the toils of sheer pettiness. The Saudi women who first drove automobiles risked and suffered penalties, overcame inhibitions, and shattered norms, heroic in their defiance of an absurd convention. We have our own Rosa Parks. That such great courage should have been required to challenge such petty barriers is a demonstration of the power of social consensus. How many minor coercions are required to sustain similar customs and usages? How aware are any of us, absent direct challenge, of how we also deal in trivial coercion? [...] Cultures commonly employ the methods of cults, making their members subject and dependent. And nations at intervals march lockstep to enormity and disaster. A successful autocracy rests on the universal failure of individual courage. In a democracy, abdications of conscience are never trivial. The demoralize politics, debilitate candor, and disrupt thought.
Post a comment
Powered
by |