choof.org

Choof.org is Chris Hoofnagle's personal site. You'll find postings from the Federal Register here, interesting Washington regulation tidbits, and my newest feature, the Daily Data Marketing Wake Up Call. Enjoy.

Fam

Father Jay
Mother Cheryl
Brother Holden
Brother Mark
Reenhead (soon to be fam)

Friends

Dan Solove
Laura Quilter's Derivative Work
Mary Hodder's Napsterization
Carrie McLaren's Stay Free
Lauren Gelman's Gelman Blog
Jennifer Granick
Declan
Milana

Decent Links

Hoofnagle Del.icio.us
Utility Fog Blog
Berkeley IP Weblog
Joe Gratz
Memepool
Robot Wisdom
Cryptome
Seth Schoen
Simson Garfinkel
Corporate Crime Reporter
Modern Drunkard Magazine
Divinest Sense
Adam Shostack's Emergent Chaos
Ryan Singel's Secondary Screening

Archive

July 2005
June 2005
May 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004
September 2004
August 2004












Syndicate This!

RSS 1
RSS 2
RSD

Categories

Art (3)
Cards (9)
Commercialism (43)
Consultants (2)
Customer No Service (1)
Degrading Women (1)
Drunk (9)
Federal Register (5)
First Amendment (9)
Health Code Violations (2)
Human Rights (5)
Jeebus (17)
Lysenkonomics (6)
Marketing (46)
Music (5)
News (225)
Privacy (36)
SUV (5)
Samuelson (1)
Scams (1)
Whoredom (32)



















October 09, 2004

Is Economics A Science?

Professor Leiter has reposted a great discussion on economics and its status as a science. BTW: Did you know that the Nobel Prize for economics isn't really a Nobel? Check out this post where it is explained that the Bank of Sweden, in order to heighten the status of the field of Economics, endowed the award in the 1960s.

Update: I finally found this 2001 Article from the New York Times that more fully describes the origin of the imitation Nobel Prize:

...The prize was tacked on to the original awards in 1969 as a marketing ploy on behalf of Sweden's central bank...

...officially the Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel - has long been disdained by other laureates. Murray Gell-Mann, who won his Nobel in physics the year that economists were first honored, said he shocked a colleague when he mentioned the two winners of the economics prize while describing the awards ceremony. "You mean," the colleague said, aghast, "they sat on the platform with you?"

Of course, economics as a distinct discipline is a creation of the 20th century. Economists have little patience with scientists who fret that economics is not a "hard" science. "Whether economics is a science or not is irrelevant," said David Romer, an economics professor at the University of California at Berkeley. "It's serious scholarship, and it's great to have that recognized."

...Even in the early years, when acknowledged giants like Paul A. Samuelson, Milton Friedman and Kenneth Arrow were being honored with economics Nobels, Swedes as prominent as Gunnar Myrdal issued calls to abolish the prize. Even grateful recipients have sometime expressed reservations. Friedrich Hayek, whose reputation for Viennese courtesy rivaled that for his libertarian views, toasted the King and Queen of Sweden during the Nobel banquet by saying that, had he been consulted, he would have "decidedly advised" against creating the prize in the first place.

Posted by chris at October 9, 2004 09:40 AM

Comments

Post a comment














Search this site:

Match case Regex search

Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.

Powered by
Movable Type 3.17